Judges and Unjust Laws

Judges and Unjust Laws
Author :
Publisher : University of Michigan Press
Total Pages : 336
Release :
ISBN-10 : 9780472034154
ISBN-13 : 0472034154
Rating : 4/5 (54 Downloads)

Book Synopsis Judges and Unjust Laws by : Douglas E. Edlin

Download or read book Judges and Unjust Laws written by Douglas E. Edlin and published by University of Michigan Press. This book was released on 2010-07-22 with total page 336 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: "With keen insight into the common law mind, Edlin argues that there are rich resources within the law for judges to ground their opposition to morally outrageous laws, and a legal obligation on them to overturn it, consequent on the general common law obligation to develop the law. Thus, seriously unjust laws pose for common law judges a dilemma within the law, not just a moral challenge to the law, a conflict of obligations, not just a crisis of conscience. While rooted firmly in the history of common law jurisprudence, Edlin offers an entirely fresh perspective on an age-old jurisprudential conundrum. Edlin's case for his thesis is compelling." ---Gerald J. Postema, Cary C. Boshamer Professor of Philosophy and Professor of Law, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and author of Bentham and the Common Law Tradition "Douglas Edlin builds a powerful historical, conceptual, and moral case for the proposition that judges on common law grounds should refuse to enforce unjust legislation. This is sure to be controversial in an age in which critics already excoriate judges for excessive activism when conducting constitutional judicial review. Edlin's challenge to conventional views is bold and compelling." ---Brian Z. Tamanaha, Chief Judge Benjamin N. Cardozo Professor of Law, St. John's University, and author of Law as a Means to an End: Threat to the Rule of Law "Professor Edlin's fascinating and well-researched distinction between constitutional review and common law review should influence substantially both scholarship on the history of judicial power in the United States and contemporary jurisprudential debates on the appropriate use of that power." ---Mark Graber, Professor of Law and Government, University of Maryland, and author of Dred Scott and the Problem of Constitutional Evil Is a judge legally obligated to enforce an unjust law? In Judges and Unjust Laws, Douglas E. Edlin uses case law analysis, legal theory, constitutional history, and political philosophy to examine the power of judicial review in the common law tradition. He finds that common law tradition gives judges a dual mandate: to apply the law and to develop it. There is no conflict between their official duty and their moral responsibility. Consequently, judges have the authority---perhaps even the obligation---to refuse to enforce laws that they determine unjust. As Edlin demonstrates, exploring the problems posed by unjust laws helps to illuminate the institutional role and responsibilities of common law judges. Douglas E. Edlin is Associate Professor of Political Science at Dickinson College.


Judges and Unjust Laws Related Books

Judges and Unjust Laws
Language: en
Pages: 336
Authors: Douglas E. Edlin
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2010-07-22 - Publisher: University of Michigan Press

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

"With keen insight into the common law mind, Edlin argues that there are rich resources within the law for judges to ground their opposition to morally outrageo
The Long Arc of Legality
Language: en
Pages: 491
Authors: David Dyzenhaus
Categories: History
Type: BOOK - Published: 2022-01-27 - Publisher: Cambridge University Press

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Explores how the central question of philosophy of law is the legal subject's: how can that be law for me?
Limits of Legality
Language: en
Pages: 367
Authors: Jeffrey Brand-Ballard
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2010 - Publisher:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Judges sometimes hear cases in which the law, as they honestly understand it, requires results that they consider morally objectionable. Most people assume that
Common Law Theory
Language: en
Pages: 262
Authors: Douglas E. Edlin
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 2010-10-18 - Publisher: Cambridge University Press

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

In this book, legal scholars, philosophers, historians, and political scientists from Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the United States
Justice Accused
Language: en
Pages: 340
Authors: Robert M. Cover
Categories: Law
Type: BOOK - Published: 1975-01-01 - Publisher: Yale University Press

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

What should a judge do when he must hand down a ruling based on a law that he considers unjust or oppressive? This question is examined through a series of prob